Systematic Destruction of Institutions to Paralyze Railways: Part-I

“You show me the face, I will show you the rule.”

Mismanagement in DRM Postings: Series of questionable policy tweaks and partisan decisions which destroyed an institution

A major stir has begun in Indian Railways after the issue of DRM (Divisional Railway Manager) postings was raised by #Railwhispers. Several officers from all zonal railways are continuously sending in information.

Indian Railways is one of the few Government departments which is operational in nature. It runs more than 20,000 trains every day carrying crores of passengers and thousands of crores worth of goods. That is a herculean task by any standards which is second only to the defence forces.

Traditionally, there were three well established institutions in Indian Railways, which formed the spine of the organization:

  • At apex level, Railway Board
  • At Zonal Railway level, General Manager
  • At divisional level, Divisional Railway Manager

These three institutions formed a robust iron core, around which the Railway system worked like clockwork. However, over the past few years, all these three institutions have been severely damaged by ill-conceived policy shocks and partisan postings aimed at benefiting a few undeserving officers.

How the institutions of Railway Board and General Manager have been undermined will be detailed in subsequent parts of this series. However, the most damaging blow has been to the institution of DRM, simply because DRM is the head of the field organization which actually runs the trains and maintains the railway assets. The institution of DRM has been undermined by a series of bad decisions.

Over the past decade, a number of complaints regarding ad-hocism and lack of transparency in DRM postings were lodge before various high functionaries including PMO. As a result, the need was felt for a clear and transparent policy for DRM postings. Under tremendous pressure from PMO and DoPT, the norms for posting of DRMs were finalized and issued by Ministry of Railways vide letter no. E(O)III-2016/PL/02 Dated 16.08.2016. These norms retained long standing age limit of 52 years and the cut-off date of 1st July for eligibility for DRM. However, an element of discretion was given to CRB, opening room for manipulation. This was questioned by various stake holders and even a starred question regarding the same was asked in Loksabha by TRVS Ramesh (copy enclosed).

Still these norms were implemented and were functional for five years. However, the mischievous elements in Railway Board started manipulating the orders of DRMs by bending rules. As a result, various DRM orders were delayed with the objective of giving benefit to specific officers. In November 2021, tenure of 21 DRMs posted vide order dated 16.11.2019 ended, but the orders of their successors were delayed by almost a year. Finally, the orders were issued on 07.10.2022. Due to this large number of capable and eligible officers, they lost the chance of becoming DRM.

There are multiple other incidences where the orders for posting of DRMs were delayed in an arbitrary manner to give benefit to certain favoured individuals. But such piecemeal manipulation was not enough for the crooked minds occupying high offices in Railway Board. They wanted more.

As a result, the Norms for DRM were again revised vide Railway Board letter no. E(O)III-2024/PL/04 Dated 03.09.2024 (copy enclosed). In these norms the cut-off date for reckoning the maximum age (52 years) for DRM empanelment was changed from 1st July to 1st January. This change had the effect of denying the eligibility of DRM to a large number of officers who would have been eligible as per the norms in force since past many decades. At the same time, it brought an equally large number of ineligible officers into the zone of eligibility. This was fresh business for the crooked minds sitting in Railway Board.

Two policies issued over 8 years regarding Norms for DRM empanelment, both directed to facilitating manipulation but conveniently ignoring the issue which actually needs to be addressed: Rationalization of departmental quota for DRMs. The department wise distribution of DRM posts, still remains lopsidedly in favour of officers coming from Civil Services and non-operational departments with Traffic, Accounts, Stores and Personnel getting 24 posts. On the other hand operationally important departments like Elecrical and S&T having just 10 and 6 posts as against 14 posts each for Traffic, Mechanical and Electrical. Why can’t the distribution of DRM posts be only to departments involved in operations and that too in proportion of their cadre strength?

These policy changes and manipulation in orders did not affect one panel but had the cascading effect on all subsequent DRM panels. As a result, large number of court cases were there from aggrieved officers in CATs. In most cases, the courts ruled in favour of aggrieved officers. However, instead of uniformly complying with all such court orders, the manipulative masterminds in Railway Ministry, with the help of crooked RBSS officials, devised a novel scheme. In some cases, where the aggrieved officer obliged these masterminds in cash/kind, the CAT orders were implemented but in other cases Railways went for appeal in High Courts. The cases lingered on for years and the aggrieved officers were promoted to HAG and a plea was taken before the courts that HAG officers cannot be posted as DRM as per policy.

As reported earlier, yet again efforts are underway to flout the norms to post HAG officers as DRM. Classic example of the frequently used policy of Ministry of Railways, “You show me the face, I will show you the rule.”

These blatant manipulations have had a devastating effect of killing the institution of DRM. The results are clearly visible. Those who become DRM by manipulation and corruption, shamelessly practice corruption. After all, they have to recover whatever they have offered to the Gods sitting in Ministry of Railways for becoming DRM, with a handsome premium. No wonder the allegations of corruption against DRMs are increasing. Recent example being CBI trap cases against Saurabh Prasad, DRM Waltair and Vineet Singh, DRM Guntakal. Both these officers have since been removed from service under rule 56(j). Incidentally, both these officers are from the same cadre (IRSME) from which the present CRB hails.

DRM being a very senior and extremely important post, during earlier postings (before 2022), options were taken from empaneled officers about the divisions they wanted to be posted in. However, final postings were done considering their options as well as administrative convenience. So while nobody was assured of choice posting, the officers at least had the satisfaction that they were being heard. Also, all eligible officers got an equal chance to express their choices. This reinforced the officers’ faith in administration and accordingly they worked with fairness and zeal after posting as DRM.

In addition, views of all the board members were taken before finalizing posting of DRMs, even though CRB had the final word. This was a democratic and transparent system which had stood the test of time and had the faith of all Railway officers.

After 2022, the system of uniformly taking options from all eligible officers was discontinued. Consultation with board members was also discontinued by the present CRB-On-Contract. This was done so that the manipulative minds sitting at the helm of Railway Board could post DRMs as per their whims and fancies in corrupt collusion with selected few eligible officers. 

Rumors are ripe that in the panel of DRM which is being formed, certain eligible officers have been consulted and assured of their choice postings. Most of these privileged officers are either from IRSME cadre or are from a particular caste and community.

When the head of the division is appointed by corrupt practices and manipulation, no wonder corruption has become rampant at grassroots level, as is being reported regularly in this forum. Intervention from PMO and CBI investigation is requested to put a check to institutionalized corruption in DRM postings. To be continued..