Railway Procurement Audit Reveals Severe Compliance Lapses in Rites Certification Procedure

Inspite of exposure of lapses or wrong doings- RITES has continued with same lapses in further inspection

No documents on import of Raw material from approved Sources

A comparative analysis of two official inspection certificates issued by RITES Limited for component supplies to Chittaranjan Locomotive Works (#CLW) exposes significant disparities in document verification and standard operating procedures. The findings highlight crucial compliance gaps in the verification process for high-value locomotive components supplied to Indian Railways.

The first document, Certificate Number 1385407, details an inspection conducted on November 24, 2025, for M/s Selvoc Engineering Company Pvt Ltd. The purchase order, valued at over ₹6.71 crore, covered 7,261 rotor bars for Scheme-I rotors. The inspection carried out by Inspecting Engineer Palash De cleared the entire offered lot of 7,261 units. However, crucial supporting documentation for major technical components was omitted.

The document list associated with the inspection fails to include raw material import documents or raw material test certificates, and notably lacks an OEM-approved Quality Assurance Plan (#QAP). The uploaded files consist only of photographs, a generic test plan, and a lab report, with zero records of raw material traceability or approved QAP references in the remarks.

In stark contrast, Certificate Number 4772975, issued on June 22, 2024, by Inspecting Engineer Suresh Kumar Suman for M/s Applied Engineering Services, demonstrates a complete adherence to standard procedure. Covering an order of 7,000 stamping-type resistance rings, the inspection explicitly notes that approval was granted specifically on the basis of an OEM-approved Quality Assurance Plan.

The accompanying documentation uploaded to the IREPS system includes a comprehensive paper trail consisting of the OEM Raw Material Test Certificate (OEM-RMTC), an Approved QAP, internal test reports, offer general certificates, drawing specifications, and test witness reports alongside standard inspection images.

The direct comparison between the two certificates demonstrates a marked failure of standard oversight in the case of Selvoc Engineering Company. While Applied Engineering Services was held to strict compliance—requiring documented proof of raw material origins, internal testing, and an officially sanctioned QAP before clearance was granted—Selvoc Engineering Company received clearance for a multi-crore supply without uploading raw material import/test certificates or a valid QAP to the system.

The clearance of raw materials and finished products without verifiable origin records or an approved quality plan bypasses essential safety protocols designed to ensure the structural integrity of electrical equipment in passenger and freight locomotives.